Lisa M. Lane wrote a elegant post on Three Kinds of MOOCs on her blog the other day, and it has me thinking and reconsidering. She organized current MOOCs into three categories: Network-based, Task-based, and Content-based. The brilliant part of this classification scheme is that all three principles (network, task and content) are part of all three types of MOOCs; it is just that each type has an emphasis on one of those principles.
Why do I like this? Because it is at the heart of my attempts to adapt MOOC elements into my courses. As I've said before, the MOOC is just a stepping stone. It provides us with a new educational paradigm. Not all courses have to be massive or open to take advantage of the ideas that have been sparked for the MOOC. I also contend that the MOOC is not for all people or learning levels. With Lisa Lane's classification, I need to refine the last thought a little.
The network-based MOOC has an emphasis on the evolving conversation and learning networks, and is indicative of the first generation of MOOCs. My thoughts regarding the level of the learner/student is most focused on this type of MOOC. Last week's #MOOCMOOC seemed mainly focused on generating conversation, even though there were tasks involved. The building of a learning network was critical. But this type of MOOC requires some level of understanding, life experience, and intellectual maturity. The full format does not work well with most undergraduates, especially when you are trying to help them build up the mental framework of a discipline. Putting a Freshman into such as situation would only add disconnections (but this may well change in the future).
The task and network-based approaches are more in line with helping students build up their intellectual strengths. This is where I'm focused. Adapting the tools and principles of the original MOOCs to build courses that help students tackle content, build mental frameworks (content in context), and recognize the importance of the learning community/network.
Now, I would not call what I do as MASSIVE. First, I'm really bad at publicity, so most people don't know about project BOLO. I do want the course and materials to be open, because having other people come in adds perspective to the discussions. My primary focus though is going to be the students I have in class (I will comment to everyone, but my commitment is to those enrolled in the campus course). These are reasons I see what I'm doing as based on MOOCs, but not an actual MOOC.